When you see a person with spinach in their teeth, are you the type to tell them or to let the next person tell them?
On the one hand, it’s an awkward moment. On the other, finding out later can be even more painful.
I feel that way about editing projects sometimes. You’re hired for a copyedit (spelling, grammar and style) and you realize that there are elements missing that will leave the reader confused. Or that the piece does not deliver what the writer promised.
The structural edit is the spinach in the teeth.
Sometimes I can just add a few comments here and there, but when the problem is really apparent, I tell them: you need a structural (or substantive) edit.
A structural edit looks at the big picture of a piece. That might mean moving sections around, adding missing information, or checking a source and swapping in a new one. Editors Canada’s list of editing definitions offers even more on what it involves: https://editors.ca/hire-an-editor/skills/
If a piece needs work, so much will change with the structural edit that it is not worth tidying the copy. If a client questions the need for this structural pass, I often offer a couple of examples of what I can fix. Then they agree on the need. Most times.
Spinach in the teeth is never fun, but it can be fixed.
I also share these blog posts on LinkedIn – visit https://www.linkedin.com/in/sbowness/ to connect with me there. Or hire me to help you develop your content strategy!


